Comparing the Alternatives
‣
Air Handler Locations: Pros and Cons
Location | Pros | Cons | Best for |
1. Rooftop (packaged RTU or AHU on a curb or steel frame) | • Uses no interior floor space<br>• Short, easy outdoor air and exhaust ducts<br>• Intakes sit far from street-level fumes<br>• Lowest first cost; quick to install<br>• Ducts drop straight down to the floors below | • Exposed to weather, so it wears out sooner (15–20 years vs. 25–30+ indoors)<br>• Hard to service in bad weather; needs fall protection and guards (IMC 304.11)<br>• Curbs and roof openings can leak<br>• Needs extra structure; replacement needs a crane<br>• Noise and vibration reach the top floor<br>• Visible; may need a screen<br>• Intakes must keep ASHRAE 62.1 separation distances<br>• Heat loss and coil freeze risk in cold climates | Low-rise commercial, retail, schools, warehouses |
2. Rooftop penthouse | • Weather-protected, so it lasts longer and is easier to service<br>• Keeps short roof-level intake and exhaust<br>• Allows larger custom units (better filters, energy recovery, quieter fans)<br>• Blocks noise and hides equipment | • Costs more than a rooftop unit (you build an enclosure)<br>• May count toward height or floor-area limits<br>• Roof still carries the weight<br>• Replacement still needs a crane or knock-out panels | Mid-rise offices, labs, hospitals in harsh climates |
3. Ground-floor mechanical room | • Easiest to maintain and replace (drive-in access)<br>• Slab carries the weight and vibration<br>• Close to the central plant and utilities<br>• Weather-protected; long life | • Uses the most valuable floor space (retail, lobby)<br>• Intakes at grade pull in exhaust, dust and fumes; security risk<br>• Large shafts take space on every floor<br>• Long ducts in tall buildings mean more fan energy<br>• Louvres and noise affect the street face | Low-rise and industrial buildings where frontage is less valuable |
4. Below grade (basement) | • Uses the cheapest floor area<br>• Frees the roof and ground floor<br>• Easy to isolate noise and vibration; hidden and secure<br>• Next to a basement plant and utility entrances<br>• Stable temperatures | • Outdoor and relief air need areaways or shafts and long ducts<br>• Intake air can be poor (grade level, garages)<br>• High flood risk (groundwater, burst pipes, storm surge)<br>• Hard to replace; needs hatches or a knock-down unit<br>• Longest ducts and shafts to the upper floors<br>• May need sump pumps, waterproofing and dehumidification | Urban sites with basements, or where the roof is reserved; avoid in floodplains |
5. Intermediate mechanical floor | • One floor serves the floors above and below<br>• Shorter shafts in tall buildings<br>• Splits the building into vertical zones (manageable pressures)<br>• Fully weather-protected<br>• Can share a structural transfer or outrigger floor | • Uses a full floor that can't be rented; adds height<br>• Intakes and exhausts must go through the facade<br>• Noise reaches the floors directly above and below (may need floating slabs)<br>• Rigging equipment at mid-height is complex | High-rise buildings (roughly 20–30+ floors) |
6. Floor-by-floor AHUs | • Minimal vertical shafts<br>• Each floor or tenant has its own unit (own schedule, metering)<br>• One failure only affects one floor<br>• Small units fit in freight elevators | • Mechanical room on every floor; more total floor space lost<br>• More units to maintain (filters, controls)<br>• Each floor needs its own outdoor air route<br>• Rooms next to occupied space need acoustic treatment<br>• Higher first cost per cfm | Multi-tenant offices; often paired with a central DOAS |
7. Above ceiling (horizontal AHUs, fan coils) | • Uses no floor space<br>• Very short ducts; low fan energy<br>• Cheap; easy to split into small zones | • Small capacities only<br>• Maintenance over occupied space<br>• Condensate leak risk; needs secondary drain pans (IMC 307.2.3)<br>• Noise goes straight into the room below<br>• Needs ceiling depth and code-compliant access (IMC 306)<br>• Hard to fit high-efficiency filters or energy recovery | Small zones, retrofits, hotels, apartments |
8. Exterior at grade (pad-mounted) | • Uses no interior space; no roof load<br>• Easy truck and crane access<br>• Cheap to install | • Uses site area; needs a screen for looks and noise<br>• Exposed to weather and vandalism; may need fencing<br>• Ducts must pass through the foundation wall<br>• Intake air can be poor near parking<br>• Not practical for tall buildings | Single-storey buildings, campuses, industrial sites |
9. Attic or mezzanine | • Uses otherwise wasted space<br>• Short ducts to the floor below<br>• Some weather protection | • Extreme attic temperatures cause losses unless the space is conditioned<br>• Access often falls short of IMC 306.3 (catwalk, platform, lighting)<br>• Condensate and fire separation need care | Residential, light commercial, high-bay industrial |
‣
Quick Comparison Table
Location | Floor space lost | First cost | Maintenance access | Equipment life | Outdoor air quality | Duct and shaft length | Noise risk | Flood risk |
Rooftop unit | None | Low | Poor | Short | Good | Short, low-rise only | Top floor | None |
Penthouse | Low | Med–High | Good | Long | Good | Short, low-rise only | Low | None |
Ground floor | High | Medium | Excellent | Long | Fair–Poor | Long | Street, lobby | Medium |
Below grade | Low value | Med–High | Fair (rigging) | Long | Poor | Longest | Low | High |
Mid-height floor | High | High | Good | Long | Fair | Short | Floors above and below | None |
Floor-by-floor | High (total) | High | Good | Long | Fair | Very short | Adjacent rooms | Low |
Above ceiling | None | Low | Poor | Medium | Fair | Shortest | High | Low |
Exterior at grade | Site area | Low | Excellent | Short | Fair–Poor | Medium | Site neighbours | Medium |
‣
What Usually Drives the Decision
- Building height. Low-rise buildings favor rooftop units. Tall buildings favor mid-height or floor-by-floor units.
- Value of floor space. Prime retail at ground level or a roof terrace pushes equipment elsewhere.
- Outdoor air quality and security. Raise intakes above grade, keep them away from loading docks, garages and exhausts, and meet ASHRAE 62.1 separation distances.
- Climate. Harsh winters or summers favour indoor or penthouse locations over exposed units.
- Resilience. In floodplains, keep critical equipment above the design flood elevation, which effectively rules out the basement.
- Maintenance and replacement over the building's life. Plan the route for getting a 25-year-old unit out: crane, hatch, freight elevator or knock-out panel.
- Acoustics. Mechanical rooms next to sensitive spaces like conference rooms, bedrooms or labs need isolation.
- Structure. Roof and mid-height locations need extra steel or transfer structure. Ground and basement locations sit on the slab.
- Zoning and appearance. Height limits, rooftop screening rules and limits on louvres in the facade.
- Tenancy model. Single-tenant buildings tend toward central units. Multi-tenant buildings tend toward floor-by-floor units.
Videos
‣
Mindmap
Click the left or right arrows at the bottom of the mindmap to step thru the slideshow.
Resources to Download
‣
Revit Models
‣
Revit Component Families
💡
- Load other Air Handler components from this folder in the Revit Library
- Library > Mechanical > MEP > Air-Side Components > Air Handling Units