Comparing the Alternatives
‣
Duct Placement Alternatives: Pros and Cons
Alternative | Pros | Cons | Best for |
1. Fully ducted supply and return | • Best control of where air goes and how rooms are pressurized<br>• Rooms are isolated from each other, which controls odours, contaminants and sound passing between rooms<br>• Air can be measured and balanced room by room<br>• Supports high-efficiency filters and air sent to specific rooms<br>• Often required by code or standard (ASHRAE 170 healthcare, labs, cleanrooms)<br>• Fewer limits on materials above the ceiling | • Highest duct cost and the most coordination work<br>• Needs the deepest ceiling space, which raises floor-to-floor height<br>• Higher fan energy from return duct losses<br>• Costly to change when the layout changes<br>• Duct leakage and insulation must meet ASHRAE 90.1 §6.4.4<br>• Needs fire/smoke dampers where ducts pass through fire-rated walls and floors (IBC 717) | Hospitals, labs, cleanrooms, kitchens, high-performance and acoustically sensitive spaces |
2. Ducted supply, ceiling-plenum return | • Removing the return ducts saves cost and ceiling depth<br>• Lower return pressure, so less fan energy<br>• Easy to move return grilles when layouts change<br>• Light fixtures can work as returns and carry heat away | • Return air passes freely between rooms above the ceiling, so sound and odours travel and pressure can't be controlled<br>• Everything in the plenum must be plenum-rated or non-combustible (IMC 602, NFPA 90A). Cables must be plenum-rated or in conduit (NEC 300.22)<br>• Dust, leakage and contaminants in the plenum get into the return air<br>• Needs a ceiling<br>• Not allowed where rooms must be pressurized or isolated<br>• Return paths through rated walls need fire dampers or transfer ducts | Offices, schools, retail and other standard commercial spaces |
3. Underfloor air distribution (UFAD, a raised floor used as the supply plenum) | • Fan energy is low because static pressure is low and supply air is warmer, so the economizer runs more hours<br>• Better air quality where people breathe, because stratified air carries pollutants upward<br>• Very easy to change layouts by moving floor diffusers<br>• Occupants can adjust their own diffusers<br>• Cuts ceiling ducts; cabling shares the floor space | • Raised floor costs more (about 300–450 mm deep)<br>• Air leaking from the floor plenum reduces control<br>• Concrete slab stores heat, which makes the system slow to respond<br>• Hard to handle perimeter loads; needs perimeter units<br>• Spills and dirt in the plenum; floor panels must be sealed<br>• Can't pressurize individual rooms<br>• Needs careful design to manage stratification | Open-plan offices, data and trading floors, buildings with frequent layout changes |
4. Fabric (textile) ductwork | • Low cost, light weight and fast to install<br>• Air is spread evenly with few drafts and quiet airflow<br>• Can be washed; available in many colours and shapes<br>• No condensation on the duct surface<br>• Light enough for light roof structures | • Fixed layout; tears are easily damaged<br>• Must be washed regularly in dusty spaces<br>• Fire and smoke rating limits (UL 2518) restrict where it can be used<br>• Looks inflated or saggy when the fan is off<br>• Supply only; usually needs a separate return<br>• Not suited to high pressures or long branch runs | Gyms, warehouses, retail, food processing, exposed high ceilings |
5. Ductless room units (VRF or split cassettes, wall units, fan coils, PTACs) | • No duct runs, so no duct heat loss or leakage<br>• Little or no ceiling space needed<br>• Each room has its own control<br>• Lowest first cost for small zones; easy for retrofits<br>• Units can be added in stages | • Fresh air must come from a separate system such as a DOAS<br>• Low-grade filters (typically MERV 8 or lower)<br>• Fan noise is inside the room<br>• Many units spread out to maintain: filters, condensate pumps, servicing in occupied space<br>• Refrigerant concentration limits in small rooms (ASHRAE 15/34). Mildly flammable A2L refrigerants add requirements<br>• Visible units affect the look of the room<br>• Can't control room pressurization | Hotels, apartments, small offices, retrofits, historic buildings |
6. Separate fresh-air system (DOAS) plus radiant panels or chilled beams | • Moves the least air, so fan energy is lowest and ducts are small<br>• Exact control of fresh air<br>• Good comfort from radiant heating and cooling; quiet<br>• Few moving parts in occupied rooms<br>• Saves ceiling depth | • Higher first cost; needs hydronic piping throughout<br>• Indoor humidity must be held below the dew point of the cold surfaces, or condensation forms<br>• Not suited to spaces with high humidity or high air leakage<br>• Beams are fixed in place, so layout flexibility is limited<br>• Fewer contractors are familiar with it | Labs (with active beams), offices, schools, high-performance and net-zero buildings |
7. Natural or mixed-mode ventilation (no fans or ducts) | • No fan energy and the lowest running cost<br>• Simple to maintain<br>• Occupants can control it, which helps them feel connected to outdoors<br>• Supports sustainability goals | • Depends on climate and season<br>• No filtration, so it can't handle outdoor pollution or wildfire smoke<br>• Outdoor noise comes in<br>• Limited by floor-plate depth; needs openings close to each area (ASHRAE 62.1 §6.4)<br>• No pressurization control<br>• Security, rain and insect issues<br>• Usually needs mechanical backup | Schools, low-rise offices and residential buildings in mild climates |
‣
Quick Comparison Table
● Good ◐ Fair ○ Poor. The rating shows how well each option suits the criterion, so ● is always the favourable result. For example, ● under First cost means the cost is low.
Criterion | 1. Fully ducted | 2. Plenum return | 3. UFAD | 4. Fabric duct | 5. Ductless units | 6. DOAS + radiant/beams | 7. Natural vent |
First cost | ○ | ◐ | ○ | ● | ● | ○ | ● |
Fan energy | ◐ | ● | ● | ◐ | ● | ● | ● |
Ceiling or floor depth needed | ○ | ◐ | ○ | ◐ | ● | ● | ● |
Layout flexibility | ◐ | ● | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ○ |
Acoustics and room isolation | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ○ | ● | ○ |
Filtration and fresh-air control | ● | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ○ | ● | ○ |
Room pressurization and contamination control | ● | ○ | ○ | ◐ | ○ | ◐ | ○ |
Thermal comfort | ● | ● | ◐ | ● | ◐ | ● | ○ |
Ease of maintenance | ● | ● | ◐ | ◐ | ○ | ● | ● |
Looks in an exposed ceiling | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ● | ○ | ● | ● |
Code and fire-rating simplicity | ◐ | ○ | ◐ | ◐ | ◐ | ● | ◐ |
Range of climates it works in | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | ◐ | ○ |
These ratings are general. Actual performance depends heavily on design quality, climate and occupancy.
‣
What Usually Drives the Decision
- Occupancy and required standards. Healthcare (ASHRAE 170), labs, cleanrooms and kitchens usually require fully ducted, pressurized systems. Standard offices and schools allow plenum returns or other options.
- Floor-to-floor height and structure. Duct depth versus raised-floor depth affects building height, facade cost, and the number of floors allowed under a height limit.
- Air quality and filtration goals. Higher MERV ratings, wildfire-smoke resilience, and infection control favour central ducted systems or a DOAS.
- Pressurization and contamination control. Any need to isolate rooms (isolation rooms, labs, toilets, odour-producing spaces) rules out shared plenums and ductless-only systems.
- Acoustics. Conference rooms, bedrooms and studios need ducted returns with sound control, not open plenum returns or fans in the room.
- Layout flexibility and churn. Frequent reconfiguration favours UFAD or plenum returns. Fixed layouts can use any option.
- Energy targets and fan power limits. ASHRAE 90.1 §6.5.3.1 fan power limits, energy codes, and net-zero goals push toward lower air volumes: a DOAS, UFAD or plenum returns.
- Climate and humidity. Humid climates are a problem for radiant panels and chilled beams (condensation) and for natural ventilation. Mild climates make natural ventilation and economizers practical.
- Fire and smoke code. Plenum material limits, damper requirements, smoke-control systems, and rated assemblies add cost and coordination.
- First cost versus lifecycle cost. Ductless and fabric systems are cheap up front. A DOAS with radiant panels or chilled beams costs more but runs cheaper.
- Maintenance capability and access. Fewer central components suit owners with in-house staff. Distributed units mean servicing inside occupied rooms.
- Architectural intent. Exposed structure, open ceilings and historic fabric limit duct routes and favour fabric ducts, ductless units or radiant systems.
- Load density and distribution. High internal loads such as data or trading floors suit UFAD or ducted systems. Strong perimeter loads need dedicated perimeter equipment.
- Refrigerant rules. Refrigerant concentration limits for VRF and splits (ASHRAE 15/34) and the move to A2L refrigerants affect ductless systems in small rooms.
- Existing conditions (retrofits). Low ceilings, no shaft space, and heritage constraints often make ductless units or a DOAS with small ducts the only practical choice.
Videos
‣
Mindmap
Click the left or right arrows at the bottom of the mindmap to step thru the slideshow.