About Air-Based Systems
‣
Using Air as the Transport Medium
ASHRAE groups HVAC systems by what carries heating and cooling to the zones:
- All-air: the central plant conditions air and fans duct it to every zone.
- Examples: constant volume, VAV, multizone, rooftop units, residential furnace and split systems.
- All-water (hydronic): a central plant heats or chills water and pumps it to zone terminals. Ventilation is handled separately or through operable windows.
- Examples: radiators, baseboard, radiant floors, fan coils (without DOAS), unit ventilators.
- Air-water (hybrid): water handles most of the sensible load and a small ducted air system handles ventilation and humidity.
- Examples: chilled beams + DOAS, fan coils + DOAS, radiant + DOAS, induction units.
- Refrigerant-based: refrigerant itself is the transport fluid, piped to zones.
- Examples: VRF, mini-splits, packaged terminal units. These are technically fluid-based too, though the refrigerant changes phase.
‣
Pros and Cons of Air-based systems
‣
- One system does everything: heating, cooling, ventilation, filtration, dehumidification, and humidification all happen at the air handler.
- Strong humidity control: essential in humid climates and for spaces with high latent loads.
- Fast response: handles rapidly changing loads and intermittent occupancy well.
- Air-side economizers: free cooling with outdoor air when conditions allow.
- Pressurization and contaminant control: critical for labs, hospitals, cleanrooms, and kitchens.
- No water in the occupied zone: no leak risk above ceilings in tenant spaces.
- Familiar and widely understood: a large contractor and service base, simple controls in smaller systems.
- Lower first cost: in most residential and light commercial projects where cooling is needed.
‣
- High fan energy: often the largest single HVAC energy use in commercial buildings.
- Large ductwork: needs tall plenums, big shafts, and larger mechanical rooms. This adds floor-to-floor height and cost.
- Duct leakage and losses: especially in unconditioned attics and crawlspaces.
- Reheat waste in VAV: air is cooled centrally, then reheated at zones.
- Comfort issues: drafts, noise, and stratification in tall spaces when poorly designed.
- Contaminant spread: recirculating systems can move odors, smoke, and pathogens between zones unless filtration is strong.
- Zoning is harder: each zone needs a damper, VAV box, or separate unit.
- Retrofit difficulty: adding ducts to an existing building is often impractical.
‣
Fluid-based systems (hydronic and refrigerant)
‣
- Low transport energy: pumps (or refrigerant compressors in VRF) move heat far more efficiently than fans.
- Compact distribution: pipes fit where ducts cannot, saving height, shaft area, and mechanical space.
- Excellent comfort with radiant terminals: quiet, draft-free, even surface temperatures.
- Easy zoning: a valve or terminal per room.
- Efficient central plants:
- Moderate water temperatures (low-temp heating, warm chilled water) boost heat pump, chiller, and condensing boiler efficiency.
- Plants can recover heat between zones (WSHP loops, heat-recovery chillers, heat-recovery VRF).
- Thermal storage is natural: slabs and tanks can shift loads to off-peak hours.
- Retrofit-friendly: small pipes or refrigerant lines can be added to existing buildings.
- Long equipment life: for passive terminals like radiators, radiant tubing, and beams.
‣
- No ventilation, filtration, or dehumidification on their own: modern codes require mechanical ventilation, so most fluid systems still need a DOAS or ERV.
- Condensation limits for radiant and chilled beams: cooling capacity is capped by the space dew point.
- Slow response for high-mass radiant systems.
- Leak risk:
- Water piping above occupied spaces risks damage.
- Refrigerant leaks in VRF raise environmental concerns and require ASHRAE 15/34 safety checks in small rooms.
- Higher first cost: for many hydronic designs, especially radiant or dual systems (hydronic + DOAS).
- Harder layout changes: embedded or ceiling-coordinated terminals are harder to move than diffusers.
- Zone equipment maintenance: fan coils, WSHPs, and VRF indoor units have filters, fans, and drain pans spread throughout the building.
- Specialized design expertise: dew-point control, water treatment, refrigerant piping limits.
‣
Comparison of Transport Mediums
All-air | All-water | Air-water (DOAS + hydronic) | Refrigerant (VRF + DOAS) | |
Transport energy | High | Very low | Low | Low |
Distribution space | Large | Very small | Small | Very small |
Ventilation / IAQ | Integrated | Separate or none | Dedicated, precise | Dedicated, precise |
Humidity control | Strong | None | DOAS-dependent | Good (wet coils) + DOAS |
Heat recovery between zones | Limited | Plant-dependent | Plant-dependent | Built-in (heat-recovery VRF) |
Comfort | Fair–good | Very good (radiant) | Very good | Good |
Response speed | Fast | Slow–moderate | Moderate–fast | Fast |
Leak / damage risk | Low | Moderate | Moderate | Refrigerant safety concerns |
Flexibility for changes | High | Low–moderate | Moderate | Moderate |
First cost | Low–moderate | Moderate–high | Moderate–high | Moderate–high |
Operating cost | Moderate–high | Low | Low | Low |
Electrification fit | Good with heat pumps | Very good with low-temp heat pumps | Very good | Very good |
‣
Recommendations
‣
- Ventilation rates are high relative to the thermal load: classrooms, auditoriums, gyms, retail, restaurants, assembly spaces.
- Humidity or contaminant control is critical: cleanrooms, operating rooms, labs, kitchens, natatoriums.
- Climate is hot and humid, so latent load is large.
- Budget is tight and the building is small or simple, like single-family homes and small commercial spaces.
- Loads change quickly or occupancy is intermittent.
‣
- The building is heating-dominated with modest cooling needs: cold-climate homes, older multifamily, schools with operable windows.
- An existing hydronic system can be reused or electrified with low-temp emitters.
- Comfort and silence are priorities and humidity is manageable.
- Tall or large-volume spaces need heat without stratification: warehouses, garages, atriums, churches.
‣
- Designing mid- to large commercial or institutional buildings: offices, hospitals, labs, university buildings.
- Floor-to-floor height, shaft area, or retrofit constraints rule out large ducts.
- Energy performance targets are aggressive: net zero, LEED, all-electric.
- The design team can commit to proper DOAS dehumidification and controls.
‣
- The building has many small zones with diverse loads: hotels, apartments, offices, medical office buildings.
- Retrofit space is very limited.
- Simultaneous heating and cooling with heat recovery has clear value.
- Refrigerant charge limits for the occupied rooms can be met.
General guidance:
- Let ventilation and humidity requirements size the air system, then move the remaining thermal load with the most efficient fluid that fits the building.
- Go all-air only when air volumes are large anyway for ventilation or contaminant control, or when first cost and simplicity outweigh lifetime energy savings.
Videos
‣
Mindmap
Click the left or right arrows at the bottom of the mindmap to step thru the slideshow.