Module 6 - Points to Ponder

Submitted For
Module 6 - Points to Ponder
💡
Please share your comments on 3 of the following 5 questions.

Which structural framing systems and materials are most commonly used in the United States for residences? For office buildings?

◦  What factors explain why those dominate?

◦  Why did you choose your system, and what did it cost you?

You sized members by judgment rather than analysis.

◦  What did you base your first guess on?

I estimated my concrete beam and column sizes based on the building layout and spans. Starting larger is generally safer because undersized members could cause structural problems. In a real project, the structural engineer would calculate the loads and adjust the sizes accordingly.

◦  Why is it safer to guess large and shrink than to guess small and grow?

◦  At what point in a real project does the engineer take over from the guess?

Design teams link and share models rather than working in one file.

◦  What are the advantages of linking?

Linking models allows architects and engineers to work separately while coordinating their designs. However, incorrect shared coordinates can cause misalignment and inaccurate clashes. Setting coordinates correctly from the beginning prevents major rework later.

◦  What errors does linking make possible that a single model would not?

◦  Why is getting shared coordinates right at the start so much cheaper than fixing it later?

Not every clash is a problem.

◦  On what basis did you classify a clash as an issue versus not an issue?

My Revit interference check identified 778 clashes, but not all were actual problems. I prioritized intersections affecting doors, windows, and usable space over expected structural connections. In a real project, the architect and relevant engineers should coordinate before closing a clash.

◦  Who should have authority to close a clash on a real project?

Your beam depths just constrained next week's ductwork.

◦  Where in your building is the ceiling plenum now tightest?

◦  What would you give up to get it back?

◦  Should the structural engineer have consulted the mechanical engineer before setting spans?