Which structural framing systems and materials are most commonly used in the United States for residences? For office buildings?
wood framing for residences and metal frames over concrete for office buildings
◦ What factors explain why those dominate?
wood is very cheap and relatively sturdy, so it works well for smaller buildings. Metal and concrete is a more stable combo, so it’s neccessary for large buildings that need the support.
◦ Why did you choose your system, and what did it cost you?
Metal and concrete, because it is a really large building and needs the stability. It cost me space on the lower floor as well as is worse for the environment.
You sized members by judgment rather than analysis.
◦ What did you base your first guess on?
rules of thumb from my architecture studio and the general size of my spans.
◦ Why is it safer to guess large and shrink than to guess small and grow?
If you have to grow, you might not have space, whereas shrinking means you will always guarantee that you have space.
◦ At what point in a real project does the engineer take over from the guess?
When an entire system is established, and you have to move on to the plumbing and mechanical work
Design teams link and share models rather than working in one file.
◦ What are the advantages of linking?
You can get automatic updates as the other model changes. Design is constantly done in tandum with new iterations that affect the other disciplines as a building is getting built. You want these updates.
◦ What errors does linking make possible that a single model would not?
If there’s issues with it updating and the information staying current and accurate, many poor decisions can be made due to false information.
◦ Why is getting shared coordinates right at the start so much cheaper than fixing it later?
A lot of elements rely on the shared coordinates as your work. Elevation measurements, carrying beams across, grids from the architecture model…