Module 7 - Points to Ponder

Submitted For
Module 7 - Points to Ponder
💡
Please share your comments on 3 of the following 5 questions.

Your loads were determined by decisions you made weeks ago.

◦  Which single earlier decision had the largest effect?

◦  If you could go back to Week 3 knowing this, what would you change?

◦  Who on a real project team should have raised this, and when?

Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.

◦  What else determines whether an occupant feels comfortable?

Comfort also depends on the surrounding surface temperatures (mean radiant temperature), humidity, air speed, and what the occupant is wearing and doing. Glare, noise, and stale air matter too, which is why my strategy pairs operable windows with an ERV.

◦  Which of those can your model predict, and which can it not?

My model predicts peak heating and cooling loads, supply airflow, outdoor air quantities, and the 70°F heating and 75°F cooling setpoints with a 70 percent humidity limit. It cannot predict the cold-window radiant effect at the corner units, drafts from diffusers, or individual clothing and activity, so it never calculates whether a specific person feels comfortable.

The Bay Area has a mild climate.

◦  Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?

◦  What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?

You computed loads for one typical floor.

◦  Which floors in your building would have a different loads, and why?

Floor 7 sits directly under the roof, so it gains summer heat and loses winter heat through the roof that Floor 1 never sees. Floor 0 holds retail on a slab-on-grade with storefront glazing and much higher occupant and equipment loads, so its loads would look nothing like the apartments.

◦  Would the system you modeled for your two units still work on those floors, or what would you change?

On Floor 7, the same in-unit heat pumps and 600 CFM fan coils still work, since my largest unit needs only 530 CFM, and the refrigerant runs to the roof get much shorter. The ground-floor retail needs its own system, likely a larger packaged or split unit per tenant, because its loads, hours, and ventilation needs differ from an apartment’s.

You were told not to agonize over duct connections.

◦  What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?

A detail matters now if it changes a design decision or a number I report, like the 2'-3" plenum height that set my trunk elevation or the duct crossings that decided my alternative. A detail can wait if fixing it later changes nothing upstream, like the exact flex duct lengths or a fitting that didn’t join cleanly.

◦  How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?

I would know when a deferred item forces me to redo an earlier decision, the way my refrigerant runs of 125 to 190 feet now push the condensers toward the shaft and reopen the roof layout. A good test is to ask whether the item could change equipment location, ceiling height, or a code requirement.