Your loads were determined by decisions you made weeks ago.
◦ Which single earlier decision had the largest effect?
◦ If you could go back to Week 3 knowing this, what would you change?
◦ Who on a real project team should have raised this, and when?
Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.
◦ What else determines whether an occupant feels comfortable?
Besides air temperature, comfort depends on humidity, air movement, radiant temperature, clothing, and activity level. For example, residents sitting near the WNW-facing windows in Unit 204 might feel warmer because of direct sunlight.
◦ Which of those can your model predict, and which can it not?
My Revit model estimates heating and cooling loads and required airflow, but it does not directly predict how occupants experience radiant heat, drafts, or personal comfort. It also cannot account for individual preferences, such as clothing or activity.
The Bay Area has a mild climate.
◦ Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?
I think cooling is most important in apartments with greater exterior exposure, especially Unit 204 WNW, which has the highest cooling intensity at 8.54 Btu/h·SF. I would also expect the uppermost residential floor to need more cooling because of roof heat gain.
◦ What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?
I would need better window shading, glazing, and natural ventilation. However, eliminating mechanical cooling could mean less consistent indoor temperatures, especially during hot afternoons. Residents might also have to keep their windows open despite outdoor noise or poor air quality.
You computed loads for one typical floor.
◦ Which floors in your building would have a different loads, and why?
The top residential floor would likely have different loads because of direct roof exposure. The ground-floor commercial spaces would also have different loads due to their occupancy, glazing, and operating schedules.
◦ Would the system you modeled for your two units still work on those floors, or what would you change?
I would still consider using FCUs for the residential floors, but I would recalculate the loads and adjust the equipment capacities and airflow. I might also need to change the duct routes depending on the available ceiling space and structural layout. For the commercial floor, I would use a separate HVAC system because its requirements are different.
You were told not to agonize over duct connections.
◦ What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?
◦ How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?