Your loads were determined by decisions you made weeks ago.
◦ Which single earlier decision had the largest effect?
My decision about how much glass to include in the facade had the largest effect on the loads. Windows are the largest heat loss on both floors I studied, making up 40% of L01’s heating and 44% of L02’s. The corner units show this the most. The six corner units on the LO2 have windows on two facades, so they hold a whole 60% of the floor’s total glass and need more than half of its heating, even though they are less than half (40%) of its area.
◦ If you could go back to Week 3 knowing this, what would you change?
I would reduce the glass on the corner units’ second facade, since those units are already getting sunlight and I think it would be more important to cut heating load than to give those units a surplus of light.
◦ Who on a real project team should have raised this, and when?
The energy consultant or a mechanical engineer should have raised this issue during the early schematic design, while the massing and facade options were still being compared (our Weeks 2–3). A quick early energy model would have flagged the corner glass as an issue.
Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.
◦ What else determines whether an occupant feels comfortable?
◦ Which of those can your model predict, and which can it not?
The Bay Area has a mild climate.
◦ Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?
◦ What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?
You computed loads for one typical floor.
◦ Which floors in your building would have a different loads, and why?
Since my building has a stepped design (with higher levels becoming smaller), the loads would also change on the upper floors. There would be fewer zones requiring heating/cooling in higher regions, so the total load on each floor gets smaller. The top floor (L08) and the parts of L06 under the step-back would also need more heating, since they lose heat through the roof. The ground floor (L01) would have the most different loads, because it is retail and lobbies instead of apartments. It has many more people, so it needs about 2.5 times the cooling per square foot of the apartment floors and much more outdoor air.
◦ Would the system you modeled for your two units still work on those floors, or what would you change?
The system I modeled for my two units could be similar on higher floors, although the size of the units changes on each floor to account for the variability in total area, so some components may have to be shifted around slightly or resized. For example, a few of the larger units (like 410, 510 and 610) need a little more airflow than the 300 CFM fan coil in unit 212, so they would need the next size up. The refrigerant lines also wouldn’t stack straight up where the building steps back. The system would not work on the ground floor, since the lobby alone needs almost ten times the airflow of one fan coil, so the retail and lobby spaces would need their own larger systems.
You were told not to agonize over duct connections.
◦ What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?
A detail that matters now is one that will have a large impact on the choices that come afterwards. For instance, selecting the size of the rooms and the placement of the walls has a major impact on following decisions, such as where the plumbing and heating/cooling equipment can go. In this module, the depth of the ceiling plenum under the steel was a detail that mattered now, because it decided where the fan coils could fit and whether the corridor ceiling had to drop. A detail that can wait is one that does not have a major impact on the design decisions that follow. If duct connections are imperfect, that is not a major issue, because someone looking at the design of the building can infer what the duct connections should look like and can still do their part of the design.
◦ How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?
I would know I had deferred something I shouldn’t have if my lack of detail had a negative impact on the next iteration of the building, or if the next iteration made it impossible for me to correct the deferred issue. For instance, if I placed walls in arbitrary places and that resulted in the plumbing being placed in strange locations, I would know that I deferred the wall placement incorrectly. I saw this in my own project with the facade. In Week 3, I never checked how much heat the windows would lose, and in Module 7 the loads showed that windows are the biggest source of heat loss, after the facade was already fixed.