Module 7 - Points to Ponder

Submitted For
Module 7 - Points to Ponder
💡
Please share your comments on 3 of the following 5 questions.

Your loads were determined by decisions you made weeks ago.

◦  Which single earlier decision had the largest effect?

The most impactful decision I made weeks ago was locating a corridor on the side most exposed to wind and cold. This worked as a buffer, separating the windiest area from the apartments and reducing the overall loads.

◦  If you could go back to Week 3 knowing this, what would you change?

knowing the actual MEP system requirements, I would reserve space for mechanical rooms on the first floor and continuous vertical shafts throughout the building from the beginning.

◦  Who on a real project team should have raised this, and when?

The MEP Coordinator should have flagged this to the Architect and the Project Manager during Schematic Design, before the building core and floor-to-floor heights were frozen. Every MEP discipline has critical spatial requirements—such as additional shafts, ceiling plenum height, and domestic water routing—so early involvement of the entire engineering team is mandatory.

Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.

◦  What else determines whether an occupant feels comfortable?

◦  Which of those can your model predict, and which can it not?

The Bay Area has a mild climate.

◦  Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?

◦  What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?

You computed loads for one typical floor.

◦  Which floors in your building would have a different loads, and why?

Due to its commercial occupancy, the first floor (Level 0) would have different loads compared to the typical floor, driven by higher internal heat gains (people, lighting, and equipment), different operating schedules, and higher air infiltration from street-level doors. Additionally, the top floor (Level 08) would have different loads due to its geometry and direct roof exposure to solar radiation and outdoor temperature swings.

◦  Would the system you modeled for your two units still work on those floors, or what would you change?

No, the residential system would not work for the first floor. The commercial loads, open-plan layout, and higher ventilation requirements are different from a typical floor, so it would need a dedicated commercial HVAC system with higher capacity and different zoning. For the top floor (Level 08), the same type of residential system could still work, but I would likely need to upsize the equipment and airflow capacity to handle the additional roof loads and its different geometry.

You were told not to agonize over duct connections.

◦  What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?

Details that cannot wait include defining the types of equipment to be used (based on the different space loads), allocating vertical shafts where necessary, and addressing anything that directly ensures occupant comfort. What can wait is defining specific duct connection types, equipment mounting details, and penetrations through non-structural walls.

◦  How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?

You know you deferred something you shouldn't have when resolving it forces you to recalculate systems, redesign the model, or trigger rework across other disciplines—for example, postponing clash detection with structural beams and later discovering that ducts don't fit in the ceiling plenum without lowering the ceiling height or rerouting the entire layout