Module 7 - Points to Ponder

Submitted For
Module 7 - Points to Ponder
💡
Please share your comments on 3 of the following 5 questions.

Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.

◦  What else determines whether an occupant feels comfortable?

Clothing, activity level, and air movement also impact an occupant's comfort level in a space. Especially indoor air quality, as good ventilation and filtration are needed to prevent stuffiness and irritation in enclosed spaces.

◦  Which of those can your model predict, and which can it not?

The model can not predict clothing and activity level since that will be dependent on the occupant’s personal choices. But the ventilation and filtration can be controlled through HVAC system equipment within Revit.

The Bay Area has a mild climate.

◦  Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?

My typical floor is level 1, on top of the ground floor of my building; floors 1-7 are residential living spaces that all follow a very similar floor setup. General mechanical cooling will be necessary for the upper floors of the residential building. Although the Bay Area has a mild climate, upper floors will be significantly hotter than the ground levels due to the roof solar load and thermal buoyancy.

◦  What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?

To remove it would require high-capacity flush ventilation at night and strict solar heat rejection, as well as a very strong envelope design. This would cost occupants higher indoor temperatures during heat waves and daily management of shading and windows in the space

You were told not to agonize over duct connections.

◦  What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?

A detail that matters now vs one that can wait is the larger concepts of needing a mechanical cooling system vs the complexities of how the ducts are connected. That is because whether or not a mechanical cooling system is used impacts the structural framing, ceiling heights, and shaft locations of the model, which has serious implications for the structural architectural plans. But the changes to duct connections are very minimal and will not necessarily impact the BIM alignment across disciplines.

◦  How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?

I would have known that I deferred something I should not have if there were spatial collisions in my model that compromised my architectural and structural designs.