Your loads were determined by decisions you made weeks ago.
One of the most significant design decisions affecting the loads was the building’s inward-facing layout. While most residential units have only one exterior-facing surface, those along the building’s edges have multiple exposed façades, resulting in greater heating demands. This was particularly noticeable along the open northern edge, where units experienced additional heat loss due to their greater exposure and north-facing orientation. Interestingly, the east–west orientation had less impact than initially expected, with internal heat gains contributing more significantly than solar gains.
The building’s layout was intentional to center the design around the adjacent park and create a shared courtyard. However, alternative unit arrangements or improved insulation along the more exposed edges could have been explored to reduce these differences in thermal performance.
Ideally, the architect and mechanical engineer would have discussed these implications during early design development. This would have allowed the team to identify particularly exposed units and explore strategies to reduce their heating demands without compromising the architectural goals of the project.
Occupant comfort is not the same as air temperature.
Beyond air temperature, occupant comfort depends on both individual choices and environmental conditions. Individual choices may include clothing, activity level, and where someone chooses to spend time within a room. Environmental factors may include humidity, air movement or direct sunlight.
The Revit model is much better equipped to estimate environmental factors as these can be evaluated using assumptions about building materials, orientation, and climate. However, individual behaviors and preferences are much harder to predict, and even environmental conditions can vary within a space. This highlights the importance of providing user-operated features, such as individual temperature controls and operable windows, to allow occupants to adjust their environment to suit their comfort.
The Bay Area has a mild climate.
◦ Where in your typical floor, and where else in your building, is mechanical cooling genuinely necessary?
◦ What would it take to eliminate it, and what would that cost the occupants?
You computed loads for one typical floor.
Although the residential layouts are generally repeated floor-to-floor, my building’s stepping geometry makes its such that there is a different exterior exposure condition on each floor. This just means that some floors have more exposed walls or roof surfaces than others which would therefore lead to different heating and cooling loads.
I believe that the the overall system that I chose will be appropriate for supplying heating and cooling to the full building. The distributed HVAC system to individual fan coils ensures that each zone is able to experience heating and cooling based on its demands. While the system itself will not need to change, there will be need for adjustments in the equipment output to accommodate the varying loads.
You were told not to agonize over duct connections.
◦ What is the difference between a detail that matters now and one that can wait?
◦ How would you know you had deferred something you should not have?