Working links to all three models in Forma Data Management and your Forma Board
Forma board:
Mechanical model:
Structural model:
Architectural model:
PDF sheet set at E1 size, 30 by 42 inches
Load summary table: floor total and by zone
Zone | Type | Floor area (sf) | People | Cooling, sensible (Btu/h) | Heating (Btu/h) | Supply air (CFM) | Outdoor air (CFM) |
L1 101 (lobby) | Lobby | 1,587 | 224 | 62,851 | 7,524 | 2,872 | 1,215 |
L1 105 (S) | Retail | 1,935 | 27 | 25,384 | 11,807 | 1,156 | 390 |
L1 106 (W) | Retail | 1,940 | 29 | 28,131 | 9,247 | 1,281 | 450 |
L1 107 (N) | Retail | 1,397 | 21 | 20,332 | 6,781 | 926 | 325 |
L1 108 (N) | Retail | 1,108 | 17 | 16,223 | 5,332 | 739 | 260 |
L1 109 (N) | Retail | 1,495 | 24 | 21,858 | 6,612 | 995 | 359 |
L1 110 (E) | Retail | 1,551 | 23 | 22,416 | 7,334 | 1,021 | 359 |
L1 111 (E) | Retail | 1,384 | 22 | 20,282 | 6,510 | 924 | 331 |
L1 112 (S) | Retail | 946 | 14 | 13,746 | 4,943 | 626 | 218 |
L1 113 (W) | Retail | 1,078 | 17 | 16,221 | 7,261 | 739 | 257 |
L1 114 (lobby) | Lobby | 580 | 82 | 23,287 | 3,511 | 1,064 | 445 |
L01 total (11 zones) | 15,003 | 500 | 270,732 | 76,861 | 12,343 | 4,610 | |
L2 200 (SW + W) | Corner unit | 531 | 4 | 4,421 | 3,125 | 201 | 52 |
L2 201 (E + SE) | Corner unit | 552 | 4 | 4,438 | 2,399 | 202 | 53 |
L2 202 (SW + W) | Corner unit | 637 | 4 | 5,057 | 3,222 | 230 | 58 |
L2 203 (S) | Unit | 433 | 3 | 3,321 | 1,156 | 151 | 41 |
L2 204 (S) | Unit | 434 | 3 | 3,317 | 1,178 | 151 | 41 |
L2 205 (S) | Unit | 505 | 2 | 3,526 | 1,424 | 160 | 40 |
L2 206 (E + SE) | Corner unit | 641 | 4 | 4,954 | 2,494 | 225 | 58 |
L2 207 (E) | Unit | 598 | 3 | 4,365 | 1,483 | 199 | 51 |
L2 208 (E) | Unit | 903 | 5 | 6,633 | 2,533 | 302 | 79 |
L2 209 (E) | Unit | 596 | 3 | 4,292 | 1,553 | 195 | 51 |
L2 210 (N + NE) | Corner unit | 1,306 | 7 | 9,721 | 4,517 | 443 | 113 |
L2 211 (N, alternative) | Unit | 918 | 4 | 6,409 | 1,904 | 292 | 75 |
L2 212 (N, base case) | Unit | 914 | 4 | 6,405 | 2,077 | 292 | 75 |
L2 213 (N + NW, multi-zone) | Corner unit | 1,531 | 9 | 12,222 | 5,546 | 556 | 137 |
L2 214 (W) | Unit | 912 | 5 | 6,770 | 2,456 | 308 | 80 |
L2 215 (W) | Unit | 661 | 3 | 4,710 | 1,819 | 214 | 55 |
L2 216 (W) | Unit | 838 | 4 | 5,900 | 1,691 | 269 | 70 |
L02 total (17 zones, 23 System-Zones) | 12,909 | 71 | 96,459 | 40,576 | 4,392 | 1,130 | |
L01 + L02 total (28 zones, 34 System-Zones) | 27,912 | 571 | 367,191 | 117,438 | 16,735 | 5,740 |
Alternatives comparison: your representative unit and your alternative unit, compared by numbers, with your conclusion
Please paste your two alternatives comparison here, what differs between them, and which you choose and why…
Unit 212 is the representative standard unit. Unit 211, its mirror-image neighbor, tests the same fan coil moved out to the corridor.
Metric | Unit 212: in-unit fan coil (representative) | Unit 211: corridor fan coil (alternative) |
Unit | 2-BD, 883 sf, north facade | 2-BD, 878 sf, mirror image of 212 |
Peak cooling (sensible) | 6,405 Btu/h | 6,409 Btu/h |
Peak heating | 2,077 Btu/h | 1,904 Btu/h |
Supply / outdoor air (design) | 291 / 75 CFM | 291 / 75 CFM |
Fan coil | 300 CFM, 9 MBH, in the unit's ceiling plenum by the entry | 300 CFM, 9 MBH, in the corridor drop ceiling outside the unit door |
Duct + flex length (supply + return) | 35 ft | 45 ft |
Supply trunk and highest velocity | 12x6, 582 FPM | 12x6, 583 FPM |
Diffusers | 3, at 97 CFM each | 3, at 97 CFM each |
Ducts through the 2-hour corridor wall | 0 | 2, each with a fire/smoke damper |
Corridor ceiling height | 9'-0" | About 8'-0" outside 211 (fan coil underside at 8'-1") |
Unit ceiling height | 9'-0" | 9'-0" |
Refrigerant line set (estimate) | About 80 ft | About 77 ft |
Service access | Access panel inside the unit, so service needs tenant entry | From the corridor through the lay-in ceiling, no unit entry |
Loads are from Systems Analysis Report 3, run with the corridors unconditioned; supply and outdoor air are the design values in the model. Duct numbers are from the model after sizing to 0.08 in. w.g. per 100 ft and 700 FPM; lengths exclude fittings and the optional ERV-212 ducts.
What differs. The two units have nearly the same loads and the same airflow, so the only real difference is where the fan coil sits, and everything else follows from that. In 212 the fan coil is in the unit's own ceiling plenum by the entry, so every duct stays inside the apartment: 35 ft of duct and flex, no ducts through the corridor wall, and 9'-0" ceilings in both the unit and the corridor. In 211 the fan coil moves to the corridor ceiling, so its supply and return have to cross the 2-hour corridor wall, each through a fire/smoke damper, and pass under the W18 girder along that wall. That adds 10 ft of duct and drops the corridor ceiling to about 8'-0". In exchange, 211 can be serviced from the corridor without entering the apartment, and its fan noise stays out of the unit. Velocities and refrigerant runs are essentially the same.
Which I chose and why. I chose the in-unit layout (212) for the standard units. It uses 22% less duct, it avoids two fire/smoke dampers that would have to be bought, wired and tested, and it keeps the corridor ceiling at full height. With the corridors now unconditioned, it also keeps the fan coil and ducts in heated space; 211's would sit in the cold corridor ceiling and need insulation. Its cost is maintenance, since servicing the fan coil means entering the apartment. That is manageable: the access panel is at the entry, and a filter-back return grille there would let tenants change filters themselves.
Design memo of 300 to 500 words: your strategy and why, what the loads told you about your envelope, where your structure got in the way, and what you left unresolved
Strategy and why. Oak Street is in California Climate Zone 3, which is mild and mostly needs heating. Climate Consultant shows only 7.8% of hours are comfortable without help, but internal heat gain and high-mass passive solar raise that to 66.6%, and cooling is only needed about 12 hours a year. So I chose a passive-first strategy: the concrete podium and cores store heat, the windows are shaded and operable, and the active system stays small. Each apartment has its own ducted heat pump fan coil in the ceiling plenum, because heat pumps heat efficiently and let each tenant control their unit. Corner units get two zones, since their two facades peak at different times. I left the corridors unconditioned because people only pass through them, and fresh air comes through heat recovery since outdoor air is cool most of the year.
What the loads told me about the envelope. Heating is driven by the envelope. Windows make up 39% of the heating peak, infiltration 20%, and exterior walls and doors about 15% each. Cooling comes almost entirely from inside (people, lights and plug loads), and the envelope barely adds to it. Corner units need almost twice the heating of a standard unit, and unit 213 loses 52% of its heat through windows on two facades. Leaving the corridors unconditioned only cut the heating peak by 12%, because the apartments now lose heat into them. Overall, my envelope priorities would be better glazing, air sealing, and insulated corridor walls and doors, while the cooling equipment can stay small.
Where the structure got in the way. The steel set the limits of the plenum. The space between the 9'-0" ceiling and the joists only fits ducts about 8 inches deep, so the trunks had to be shallow rectangles. The W18 girder along the corridor wall was the biggest problem. In the alternative (211), the fan coil's ducts had to pass under it, which dropped the corridor ceiling to about 8'-0", a main reason I chose the in-unit layout. In unit 213, two more W18 girders pushed the bedroom 2 branch into a living room bulkhead. The W18 edge girder sits in the exterior wall with only about 2 inches of ceiling space below it, so the ERV's facade ducts have to go through its web.
What I left unresolved. Systems Analysis takes occupancy from the space types, so lobby 101 is modeled with 224 people and becomes the largest load in the building, and unit 213 is overstated the same way. I need realistic people counts and a rerun before selecting equipment. The unconditioned corridors need code ventilation, and I haven't checked how cold they get in winter. The ERV's girder-web openings need the structural engineer's sign-off, and the ERV is still a placeholder. The refrigerant lines aren't modeled, and because each corner unit's zones share one heat pump in the model, I never got per-facade loads. Finally, the units outside 211–213 have diffusers but no ducts.