Working links to all three models in Forma Data Management and your Forma Board
PDF sheet set at E1 size, 30 by 42 inches
Load summary table: floor total and by zone
Alternatives comparison: your representative unit and your alternative unit, compared by numbers, with your conclusion
I compared two FCU locations: inside the apartment (Unit 206) and in the corridor (Unit 205).
I would choose Unit 206. Unit 205 has shorter ducts, lower duct velocity, and easier maintenance access, which are definitely advantages. However, it also requires a penetration through the fire-rated corridor wall. With Unit 206, I can avoid that issue and keep the ductwork within the apartment. The downside is the longer ductwork and lower entry ceiling, but I think it's a more practical option for this design.
Design memo of 300 to 500 words: your strategy and why, what the loads told you about your envelope, where your structure got in the way, and what you left unresolved
For this module, I developed an HVAC layout for the typical residential floor (B01-L02). I chose a fan coil unit (FCU) system because it allows each apartment to control its own temperature without relying on long duct runs from a central system. I divided the floor into 17 HVAC zones based on the apartment layouts and orientations. For Unit 204, I used two zones (WNW and NNE) because the spaces have different exterior exposures and cooling demands.
After setting up the conditioned spaces and reviewing the occupancy and lighting assumptions, I ran the heating and cooling load analysis in Revit. The total cooling load was 64,007 Btu/h, compared to 38,641 Btu/h for heating, with a calculated airflow of 2,915 CFM. The results showed that cooling demand was more significant for this floor. I also noticed that the loads varied depending on the location of each zone. For example, Unit 204 WNW had a cooling intensity of 8.54 Btu/h路SF, while the corridor was only 3.87 Btu/h路SF. This suggests that the exterior exposure and orientation of the apartments play an important role in their cooling requirements. It also made me consider how the building envelope, particularly the exposed fa莽ades and windows, could affect HVAC sizing.
The main difficulty during modeling was coordinating the ductwork with the structural beams. My initial duct routes crossed several beams, especially in Unit 204. I moved its FCU between the bathrooms and lowered some duct runs to pass underneath the structure. This required soffits and lower ceiling areas. In Unit 206, the entry ceiling had to be reduced to approximately 7 feet to accommodate the ducts.
I also tested another FCU location in Unit 205, placing it in the corridor instead of inside the apartment. This reduced the rigid duct length from 36'-1" to 18'-2" and improved maintenance access. However, it introduced a penetration through the fire-rated corridor wall. I would choose the in-unit arrangement in Unit 206 because it avoids that penetration, even though it requires longer ducts and a lower entry ceiling.
Some details remain unresolved, including refrigerant and condensate piping, vertical connections to the rooftop condensers, and fire-safety coordination for the corridor alternative. I also attempted Revit's automatic duct sizing, but it could not complete due to fitting connectivity issues. For now, I kept the modeled duct sizes and verified the connected air distribution systems.
For this module, I developed an HVAC system for the typical residential floor (B01-L02) of my building in Palo Alto, California. My strategy was to use individual fan coil units (FCUs) for the apartments rather than one central air distribution system. This allows residents to control their own temperatures and keeps most of the ductwork within each apartment. Considering Palo Alto's relatively mild climate, I also wanted to avoid an unnecessarily complicated HVAC system. I divided the floor into 17 HVAC zones based on apartment layouts and orientations, including two separate zones for Unit 204 because its WNW and NNE sides have different exterior exposures.
After defining the conditioned spaces and reviewing occupancy and lighting assumptions, I ran the heating and cooling load analysis in Revit. The results showed a total peak cooling load of 64,007 Btu/h, a peak heating load of 38,641 Btu/h, and a calculated airflow of 2,915 CFM. Although Palo Alto generally has a mild climate, the higher peak cooling load suggests that solar exposure and internal heat gains are important considerations for my building. The cooling intensity also varied between zones. For example, Unit 204 WNW had 8.54 Btu/h路SF, compared to 3.87 Btu/h路SF for the corridor. This suggests that the exposed fa莽ades and windows contribute to differences in cooling demand. Based on these results, I would pay particular attention to window shading and glazing on the more exposed fa莽ades.
The main challenge during modeling was coordinating the ductwork with the structural beams. In Unit 204, my initial duct routes crossed several beams, so I moved the FCU between the bathrooms and routed the ducts below the structure. This required additional soffits and lower ceiling areas. In Unit 206, the entry ceiling was reduced to approximately 7 feet to accommodate the ductwork.
I also compared two FCU locations: inside Unit 206 and in the corridor for Unit 205. The corridor option reduced the rigid duct length from 36'-1" to 18'-2" and provided easier maintenance access. However, it required a penetration through the fire-rated corridor wall. I preferred the in-unit arrangement because it avoids that penetration, despite requiring longer ducts and a lower entry ceiling.
Several details still need further development, including refrigerant and condensate piping, vertical connections to rooftop condensers, and fire-safety coordination for the corridor alternative. I also attempted automatic duct sizing in Revit, but it could not be completed because of fitting connectivity issues. I kept the modeled duct sizes and checked the connected air distribution systems instead.