Module 7 Template

Link to Student
Submitted For
Module 7 - Comfort Zone

Working links to all three models in Forma Data Management and your Forma Board

Forma board

Architectural model

Mechanical model

Structural model

PDF sheet set at E1 size, 30 by 42 inches

Chen-Building-Mech.pdf375.4 KiB

Load summary table: floor total and by zone

Metric
Unit 210
Unit 207
Total duct length (ft)
27.59
34.66
Largest duct size (in)
6x6
6x6
Highest velocity (FPM)
437.95
437.95
Clear height @ unit entry (ft)
8
8
Clear height @ corridor (ft)
11.18
9.04
Ducts crossing corridor wall
0
1
Refrigerant line set length (ft)
53.34
53.34
Maintenance access
yes
yes

Alternatives comparison: your representative unit and your alternative unit, compared by numbers, with your conclusion

The two duct systems share duct size, velocity, refrigerant distance, and unit entry clear height. As such, the two vary in duct length, corridor clear height, and ducts crossing corridor wall. The representative unit (210), has a 26% shorter total duct length, 2ft more of corridor clearance, no ducts crossing the corridor wall. As such, the duct system for the representative unit is more economical and easy to install, and thus is the chosen system.

Design memo of 300 to 500 words: your strategy and why, what the loads told you about your envelope, where your structure got in the way, and what you left unresolved

My strategy was based on my psychometric chart, where comfort, internal heat gain, passive solar direct gain (low mass), cooling and dehumidification, and heating and humidification made 99.7% of the hours in a year comfortable. From these values, I chose to use in-unit heat pumps for heating and cooling, since the climate is mild and heat pumps work best with small temperature differences. Additionally, I chose to have ERV systems for each unit to recover heat from exhaust air, which can also double for humidification. I also chose to have ducted supply from a ceiling-plenum fan coil, with one zone per unit, except for corner units, which I split by orientation.

Looking at the airflow loads from the load analysis, it is clear that the corner units had the greatest flow per area. This result supports the initial decision to split the corner units because of their higher expected load. The highest flow per area came from Unit 213-2, which is north and west facing. This orientation receives significant sunlight, and thus would be expected to have high loads compared to units that are facing in alternate directions. The second highest flow also came from a north-facing unit. It is clear that the north facing units experience the highest load, and thus the exterior wall should have higher R-values or greater shading to accommodate.

There were times when the building structure interrupted the mechanical design. When designing the duct systems, I had to iterate the height of the diffuser and ducts to ensure that they were able to connect without interfering with the existing structures.

I chose to model the mechanical system on level 3 because of the stack effect. Floors near the middle of a building experience the least amount of stack effect, which can give an average load estimate for the building. This baseline can be helpful to determine the material and equipment requirements.